Planning your thesis including publications

Aim to plan your publications as part of initial planning of the whole thesis. This reduces duplication or gaps between the papers, and involves less work than retrofitting publications to your thesis later on. Nevertheless, it’s never too late to recalibrate your plan with emerging publications in mind.

Consider how publications relate to the thesis

It's rare to have a linear, one-to-one relationship whereby each publication answers one research question completely. An example of this might be that each publication reports one experiment in a series of experiments that correspond neatly to the list of aims and hypotheses in a thesis. Even if your thesis fits this category, you still need to demonstrate how these aims and hypotheses relate together as part of a whole narrative.

More often, though, your publications will address the overarching research question in a complementary manner, for example by using different methods or focusing on different aspects of the problem. Ask:

• How do the papers complement one another and provide a nuanced answer to the research question?
• If they are in conflict, how could you resolve it or justify a more complex answer?

Sequence publications logically

Incorporate publications in an order that progresses your argument, not necessarily in the order of the writing or publication dates. It is usual to have one publication as one chapter in the thesis.

However, if it makes more sense to combine two shorter papers into one chapter, or to omit part of a publication from a chapter, explain and justify your choice clearly in the introduction to the chapter.

Learn from example theses

As part of your planning, you may find it valuable to look through a few examples of theses that include publications. Use the prompts below to help you reflect on how you could learn from examples.

1. Explore examples of thesis and chapter formats when including publications. Which thesis and chapter format resonates the most with your thesis plan?

2. Have a look at a few theses that include publications in your field or as close to your field as you can find. You can use the example theses on the Graduate Research Hub or find your own examples on Minerva. Ask:

• How many papers for publication are included as part of the thesis?
• What kind of papers are included? Empirical, theoretical, methodological or review?
• What structure does the thesis have? Does it follow an IMRAD (Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion) structure, a variation of this or a different structure? Note down its key parts.
• How would you like your thesis to be structured?

Compare you answers to the above questions to your thesis plan or map. Would you like to change anything about it?